Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

COMMENTARY

Build a strong public-private supply chain nexus

For a collaborative public-private partnership to work, the individual interests of the private sector must be brought into alignment with the requirements of the collective good.

20190826ocean.jpg

The United States is at an inflection point in its approach to supply chain management. Facing off against China, an adversary that has both a proven capability and willingness to weaponize supply chains against the United States and its allies, both the U.S. government and U.S. private companies are embracing a pivot away from efficiency to resilience.

Effectively managing this transition from efficiency to resilience, while ensuring that the United States is postured for the economic and national security threats created by hyper efficient supply chains, will require new modalities for public-private partnership.


Recent decades have demonstrated that market forces generally do produce very efficient supply chains. These supply chains, under private sector ownership, have resulted in a worldwide economy that is in some respects prosperous beyond the wildest expectations of the 18th and 19th century economists who initially pointed to the virtues of specialization.

However, this efficiency depends, in large part, on geopolitical stability. The quarter-century following the end of the Cold War proved remarkably stable. However, this stability is increasingly under threat, both by acute threats like Russia's war in Ukraine and the increasing tensions between Washington and Beijing.

A public-private approach—widely acknowledged as critical to overcoming these supply chain risks—is at the heart of a series of landmark U.S. efforts. This is demonstrated by the design of the Supply Chain Disruptions Task ForceBipartisan Infrastructure ActCHIPS and Science Act, and Inflation Reduction Act. Each embraces a partnership between the U.S. government and the private sector in addressing the supply chain disruptions that began with the COVID-19 pandemic and have evolved with rising U.S.-China competition.

The U.S. government has long recognized the value of public-private partnerships in addressing systemic challenges to supply chains. An example is the Advisory Committee on Supply Chain Competitiveness, which was established with the specific purpose of giving the Secretary of Commerce industry expert advice on a comprehensive national freight infrastructure policy. The potential of these types of partnerships is illustrated by this committee's role in raising awareness of systemic congestion and bottlenecks at ports in 2021.

However, there is often a disconnect between the public rhetoric of public-private partnerships and the reality of how they are implemented.

This is demonstrated most clearly, perhaps, in the difficulties that the White House has faced in effectively engaging with commercial actors in executing its landmark programs. As a prominent example, the CHIPS and Science Act has been criticized for picking winners and losers rather than filling gaps that the private sector is not equipped to fill. Missed opportunities for collaboration have resulted in mistrust.

Another missed opportunity is the White House's new Council on Supply Chain Resilience, which was announced with little private sector consultation. There is no doubt that coordination across U.S. government agencies, the primary mandate of this council, is indeed valuable. However, it is an open question whether this council can be effective without private sector collaboration. Building a private sector counterpart to this council, perhaps building from the model of Commerce's analogue advisory committee, seems like a policy worth considering. The three leading supply chain professional organizations—Council of Supply Chain Management Professionals, Association for Supply Chain Management, and Institute for Supply Management—could enable the objectives that this council seeks to achieve and provide a mechanism for monitoring supply chain performance.

Other examples of missed opportunities are in government-industry exchange programs. These should be ideal chances for civil servants and academicians to learn something about private sector decisionmaking. But, as documented in a 2022 report from the U.S. General Accountability Office, this has not been the case. Correcting this discrepancy would require a change to the Intergovernmental Personnel Act of 1970.

Building Resilient Supply Chains (PDF) from the Economic Report of the President (PDF) outlined the opportunities and challenges in 2022, and suggests both the need and the intent to support this kind of collaboration. However, for this collaborative public-private partnership to work, the individual interests of the private sector must be brought into alignment with the requirements of the collective good perspective and policy goals of the public sector. Both partners have useful tools and working examples to now make this vision happen.

Editor's note: This article originally appeared on the RAND Corporation's website on March 8, 2024.

Recent

More Stories

warehouse worker pulling cart

Cleo acquires DataTrans to speed procurement automation

Business software vendor Cleo has acquired DataTrans Solutions, a cloud-based procurement automation and EDI solutions provider, saying the move enhances Cleo’s supply chain orchestration with new procurement automation capabilities.

According to Chicago-based Cleo, the acquisition comes as companies increasingly look to digitalize their procurement processes, instead of relying on inefficient and expensive manual approaches.

Keep ReadingShow less

Featured

photo collage of warehouse tech

Supply chain pros are wary of inflation and labor woes

The top worries that supply chain leaders hope to address with new innovations this year include inflationary concerns (68%) and labor shortages (50%), according to a survey on innovation from the third-party logistics provider (3PL) Kenco.

And many of them will have a budget to do it, since 51% of supply chain professionals with existing innovation budgets saw an increase earmarked for 2025, suggesting an even greater emphasis on investing in new technologies to meet rising demand, Kenco said in its “2025 Supply Chain Innovation” survey.

Keep ReadingShow less
photos of white house and a loaded containership

Supply chain groups push back on Trump tariff plan

Industry groups across the spectrum of supply chain operations today are pushing back against the Trump Administration plan to apply steep tariffs on imports from Canada, Mexico, and China, saying the additional fees are taxes that will undermine their profit margins, slow their economic investments, and raise prices for consumers.

Even as a last-minute deal today appeared to delay the tariff on Mexico, that deal is set to last only one month, and tariffs on the other two countries are still set to go into effect at midnight tonight.

Keep ReadingShow less
reagan national DCA airport photo

Reagan National airport plans to reopen today after deadly crash

All flights remained grounded this morning at Washington, D.C.’s Reagan National Airport (DCA) following the deadly mid-air crash last night between a passenger jet and an Army helicopter.

In a statement, DCA airport officials said they would open the facility again today for flights after planes were grounded for more than 12 hours. “Reagan National airport will resume flight operations at 11:00am. All airport roads and terminals are open. Some flights have been delayed or cancelled, so passengers are encouraged to check with their airline for specific flight information,” the facility said in a social media post.

Keep ReadingShow less
wind turbine making electricity

GE Vernova to invest $600 million in U.S. manufacturing sites

GE Vernova today said it plans to invest nearly $600 million in its U.S. factories and facilities over the next two years to support its energy businesses, which make equipment for generating electricity through gas power, grid, nuclear, and onshore wind.

The company was created just nine months ago as a spin-off from its parent corporation, General Electric, with a mission to meet surging global electricity demands. That move created a company with some 18,000 workers across 50 states in the U.S., with 18 U.S. manufacturing facilities and its global headquarters located in Massachusetts. GE Vernova’s technology helps produce approximately 25% of the world’s energy and is currently deployed in more than 140 countries.

Keep ReadingShow less