Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Convergence accelerates—but will shippers buy in?

As 3PLs expand their value proposition through mergers and more comprehensive offerings, many shippers still continue to treat them as commodities, sabotaging both parties' chances for success.

Convergence accelerates—but will shippers buy in?

Last year, I wrote in this space about the convergence taking place in the third-party logistics (3PL) industry—that is, the convergence of fragmented logistics services with integrated logistics solutions, as well as the convergence of business models, specifically the business models of service providers, technology companies, and consulting firms.

We are halfway through 2015 and it's clear that this convergence is not only still happening, it's accelerating.


Article Figures
[Figure 1] 3PL valuations


[Figure 1] 3PL valuationsEnlarge this image

Take a look at the significant deals announced in just the past seven months (graphically represented in Figure 1):

These deals suggest that there is plenty of interest in executing more such big-ticket transactions in the weeks and months ahead.

What does this series of deals mean? For one thing, it means that investors are bullish on the 3PL industry's future growth opportunities—driven by e-commerce, global trade, companies in underserved industries (such as oil and gas) looking to move up the supply chain maturity curve, and other factors.

It also means, I believe, that the 3PL industry is becoming "barbell-shaped," with small, niche providers growing and thriving at one end; very large, global providers growing and thriving at the other end; and everybody else getting squeezed out in the middle. If you're a 3PL in the middle, the question for you now is, which end of the barbell will you race toward?

The convergence of business models is also accelerating, as these recent announcements demonstrate:

  • Ryder Introduces TranSync™, a Patent Pending, Automated Technology Tool Used to Provide Dynamic Transportation Planning
  • C.H. Robinson Introduces Freightview, a TMS for Small and Midsized Businesses
  • Transplace Launches Supply Chain Consulting Practice
  • enVista Launches New Business Entity, Enspire Commerce, Offering Enterprise Commerce Management (ECM) software platform

Simply put, the lines between 3PLs, consulting firms, and software vendors continue to blur. The Ryder and C.H. Robinson announcements, for example, underscore a point I made last year in Putting Software Vendors and 3PLs in a Box: That the answers to "What is a third-party logistics provider?" and "What is a transportation management system?" don't fit so neatly in a box any more. The boxes and labels of yesterday are giving way to a single amorphous category: "Providers of Supply Chain Software and Services."

A troubling trend
As all of this convergence accelerates, so does a troubling trend that is negatively affecting 3PL-customer relationships: Procurement organizations are looking to shift more and more risk onto logistics service providers—while also demanding lower costs, of course. To put it bluntly, many shippers still don't get it. There is no incentive for 3PLs to be innovative and creative if your objective is to beat them down on cost, shift all the risk to them, and then put the business out to bid again in one to three years. Procuring logistics services is not the same as buying paper clips, yet that's how many procurement organizations approach it.

This trend is explored in more detail in "Unpacking Risk Shifting: A White Paper Challenging Unreasonable Risk-Shifting in the Transportation and Logistics Industry," published by the University of Tennessee Center for Executive Education. I am a contributing author along with Kate Vitasek, Phil Coughlin, Peter Moore, Karl Manrodt, Emmanuel Cambresy, and Andrew Downard.

In the paper we argue that the 3PL industry is suffering from Gresham's Law, an economic principle that states bad money will drive good money out of circulation. In this context, good logistics service providers are being driven away as global shippers and consignees (GSCs) seek extreme commoditization of transportation and logistics services and also apply bad contracting practices to them.

Phil Coughlin, president of global geographies and operations at the 3PL Expeditors, shares this example, recounted by Kate Vitasek in her blog: a customer who was demanding liability terms that equated to 500 years' worth of Expeditors' revenue for a lost shipment. These types of terms and conditions put 3PLs in a very difficult position. The question for 3PLs, Coughlin said, becomes, "Do I sign the contract and hope like hell a risk does not come to fruition? Or do I walk away from a $20 million account?"

You can find the answer in the failed business relationship between Apple and GT Advanced Technologies (GTAT). Like so many companies, Apple took a "what's in it for me?" approach, where negotiations are viewed as a zero-sum game with a clear winner and loser, and the goal is to always be the winner. Meanwhile, GTAT accepted a bad agreement because it lacked the discipline to say no and walk away from a marquee customer dangling a very large revenue opportunity in front of it (emphasis on revenue, not profitability). GTAT subsequently filed for bankruptcy in late 2014. Although this was not an outsourced logistics example, it does show the costly consequences of taking a one-sided approach to supplier negotiations.

As we state in the white paper, far too many GSCs fail to recognize a fundamental flaw in their procurement practices: A "what's in it for me?" strategy is simply counterproductive. You can't convert a fundamentally weak, under-resourced, under-capitalized, unaware, or irresponsible 3PL into a responsible supplier through price concessions and shifting risk. Moreover, putting pressure on even good and credible 3PLs will simply speed up the "death spiral," running them out of business.

Be bold and different
In light of this growing trend in logistics outsourcing procurement, I have three recommendations for manufacturers and retailers: First, clearly define your desired supply chain and logistics outcomes. Second, when it's time to find the right partner to help you achieve those outcomes, recognize that you have a diversity of options today, beyond the traditional labels of 3PL, software vendor, and consultant. The best partner is the one that can provide the right combination of technology, services, and advice to help you achieve your desired outcomes. And finally, when you sit down with your 3PL partner to negotiate, be bold and different. Instead of viewing your 3PL as a "commodity" supplier and trying to squeeze every penny and shift as much risk as possible onto it, aim for something different: a relationship where the risks and rewards are shared in a fair and balanced manner; a relationship that is built on trust for the long term instead of the next bidding cycle; and a relationship that is guided by a shared vision statement focused on the end customer.

Be bold and different: That is my simple advice for shippers and 3PLs that seek profitable growth in the years ahead. Otherwise, you might find yourself caught in the middle, or in a failed relationship, with nowhere to go.

Recent

More Stories

AI image of a dinosaur in teacup

The new "Amazon Nova" AI tools can use basic prompts--like "a dinosaur sitting in a teacup"--to create outputs in text, images, or video.

Amazon to release new generation of AI models in 2025

Logistics and e-commerce giant Amazon says it will release a new collection of AI tools in 2025 that could “simplify the lives of shoppers, sellers, advertisers, enterprises, and everyone in between.”

Benefits for Amazon's customers--who include marketplace retailers and logistics services customers, as well as companies who use its Amazon Web Services (AWS) platform and the e-commerce shoppers who buy goods on the website--will include generative AI (Gen AI) solutions that offer real-world value, the company said.

Keep ReadingShow less

Featured

Logistics economy continues on solid footing
Logistics Managers' Index

Logistics economy continues on solid footing

Economic activity in the logistics industry expanded in November, continuing a steady growth pattern that began earlier this year and signaling a return to seasonality after several years of fluctuating conditions, according to the latest Logistics Managers’ Index report (LMI), released today.

The November LMI registered 58.4, down slightly from October’s reading of 58.9, which was the highest level in two years. The LMI is a monthly gauge of business conditions across warehousing and logistics markets; a reading above 50 indicates growth and a reading below 50 indicates contraction.

Keep ReadingShow less
chart of top business concerns from descartes

Descartes: businesses say top concern is tariff hikes

Business leaders at companies of every size say that rising tariffs and trade barriers are the most significant global trade challenge facing logistics and supply chain leaders today, according to a survey from supply chain software provider Descartes.

Specifically, 48% of respondents identified rising tariffs and trade barriers as their top concern, followed by supply chain disruptions at 45% and geopolitical instability at 41%. Moreover, tariffs and trade barriers ranked as the priority issue regardless of company size, as respondents at companies with less than 250 employees, 251-500, 501-1,000, 1,001-50,000 and 50,000+ employees all cited it as the most significant issue they are currently facing.

Keep ReadingShow less
diagram of blue yonder software platforms

Blue Yonder users see supply chains rocked by hack

Grocers and retailers are struggling to get their systems back online just before the winter holiday peak, following a software hack that hit the supply chain software provider Blue Yonder this week.

The ransomware attack is snarling inventory distribution patterns because of its impact on systems such as the employee scheduling system for coffee stalwart Starbucks, according to a published report. Scottsdale, Arizona-based Blue Yonder provides a wide range of supply chain software, including warehouse management system (WMS), transportation management system (TMS), order management and commerce, network and control tower, returns management, and others.

Keep ReadingShow less
drawing of person using AI

Amazon invests another $4 billion in AI-maker Anthropic

Amazon has deepened its collaboration with the artificial intelligence (AI) developer Anthropic, investing another $4 billion in the San Francisco-based firm and agreeing to establish Amazon Web Services (AWS) as its primary training partner and to collaborate on developing its specialized machine learning (ML) chip called AWS Trainium.

The new funding brings Amazon's total investment in Anthropic to $8 billion, while maintaining the e-commerce giant’s position as a minority investor, according to Anthropic. The partnership was launched in 2023, when Amazon invested its first $4 billion round in the firm.

Keep ReadingShow less